Thursday, 08 October 2009
-
Just coz you're skinny doesn't mean you're HEALTHY
Step on the scale. See a number. But what does it mean? Are you skinny or fat? Heavy or fit? Some dieters focus too much on this number, instead of focusing on changing behaviors that will help keep this number down.
Body mass index (BMI) is a very simple and commonly-used tool to assess your health by classifying you into normal weight, underweight, overweight, or obese categories. For an online BMI calculator, click HERE. However, BMI only takes your height and weight into consideration. There are many other factors that affect your health!
BMI versus Muscle Mass
Muscle weighs more than fat! But BMI doesn't take this into account! In the picture below, both men are the same height and weight. Their BMI of 33.9 would classify them as obese and at risk for cardiovascular disease. However, the man on the left exercises consistently and limits fat from his diet! He would be considered very fit and healthy. The man on the left has a body that consists mostly of fat instead of muscle. He is at high risk for cardiovascular disease!
Below is a picture of 5 pounds of fat versus 5 pounds of muscle. The 5 pounds of fat takes up so much more volume! I am 5'4 and 120 lbs, but I find people often underestimate my weight by about 10 pounds. (Or maybe they're just being polite... I don't know!) I've also seen pictures of people with the same weight/height as me, but I think, "Wow, they look a lot bigger than me!" This is because I exercise as much as I can to build and maintain lean muscle mass!
Waist Circumference
Waist circumference is also easy to administer, and more accurate in determining health than BMI. Storing fat around your abdominal is the most dangerous place to keep fat! A waist circumference greater than 35 inches (for women) or 40 inches (for men) puts you at greater risk for developing type 2 diabetes and heart disease. Don't cheat by compressing your skin with the tape measure!
Measuring Body Fat Percentage
The most accurate measure of determining your health through your weight and body composition, is to measure your body fat percentage. Unfortunately, unless you have the proper tools, it is difficult to determine your body fat percentage. I wouldn't say it is something you should be measuring as frequently as weight, but it is something useful to know and it will tell you a lot about the quality of your diet and fitness regime. Some gyms have tools to measure your body fat and some pharmacies as well (close to where the blood pressure machine is).Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis
The most accessible method to determine body fat percentage is probably bioelectrical impedance analysis. These are the machines that you find in grocery stores and pharmacies or more expensive bathroom scales. A painless electrical current is sent through your body and the flow of the current is measured. However, this method is affected greatly by how much water is in your body, your skin temperature, or recent physical activity.
Bod Pod
Before, the most accurate way of determining body fat percentage was to submerse yourself fully in water and measure the water displacement! You can imagine how silly and difficult this must be to measure.
The newest technology though has allowed body fat to be measured through volume displacement through the air. The bod pod looks like a futuristic type of space shuttle, but sitting inside one is extremely comfortable and noninvasive!
One of my professors recently purchased a bod pod for her lab. It cost her about $50000cdn! It is very recent and accurate technology, but with a large price tag! It is definitely not easy to come by. It is a common tool used by professional athletes and research nutrition. For more information on the Bod Pod: Youtube video link.
Why is Measuring Body Fat Percentage So Important?
The higher your body fat percentage, the higher your risk is for weight-related diseases such as heart disease, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, certain cancers, etc. It is absolutely possible to have a BMI in the healthy range, but a high body fat percentage that is above the acceptable range! This means you don't necessarily need to lose weight, but perhaps incorporate more strength training into your workout regimes.
Classification of Body Fat % Ranges:
Body fat also requires less calories than muscle mass. A lower body fat percentage will enable you a higher resting metabolic rate and you can eat more before gaining any weight! Muscle is more metabolically active and gives your body a leaner and more toned look. Time to pump it up at the gym!
Post a Comment
- Back to theHealthRabbit's Xanga Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in theHealthRabbit's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)




Comments (20)
About a year or two ago I took my BMI and apparently I was at 11% body fat. I'm pretty sure I'm not that low anymore haha.
exactly!! i hate it when ppl say i'm overweight or some crap like that.. or when ppl don't understand that i lose weight coz i haven't been working out.. muscle weighs MORE than fat!!
This was certainly an interesting read.
I have a bathroom scale that gives body fat% and water%, and it's really interesting.... but I think it's really really wrong. It told me that I have 18% body fat, but I'm not an athlete by any definition. I definitely take it with a grain of salt.
this is why i rarely go by weight numbers and instead by bmi and eyeballing the waist.
Damn...and I thought that I could get away with being naturally thin. =P
yapyap..
i measure my fat%.... not weight!!!
Very informative!
ugh the fat takes up almost 3x the space that muscle takes up!
I am definitely going to the gym tomorrow. haha.
There is also the 7 spices' of being healthy.
The prof that just got the body pod, what kind of research does that prof do?
Passby ~^^
@yelly - Dr Andrea Buchholz focuses on body composition and energy metabolism :)
Her website is here with some of her research topics/papers if you're interested:
http://www.family.uoguelph.ca/page.cfm?id=691
liked this entry. very informative. thanks! :]
Hi! I've been reading your site for a few days now and just want to say thank you for sharing such valuable information with us about nutrition. Actually I'm considering to major in Nutrition so your blog really caught my attention. I'm just a freshmen at college and taking few core class now, but just want to ask, what can a student of Nutrition expect? I've always been interested in finding out what food is good for the health and etc. Also I love food and cooking in general. If you have any advice or suggestion, would you mind sharing some? :) And again thanks for sharing such cool info with us! I learned a lot from just reading a few posts. :) Keep up the great work! :)
BMI can be very deceptive. There are some skinny people with a lot of fat around their organs. These fat are the very dangerous ones. These are typical cases for people who starve themselves, or are dieting. People who exercise regularly usually don't have that much fat around their organs.
@o4ear - Hi there :) thanks for the comment! What I can tell you about my major is that... when I was in 1st and 2nd year, I found the courses really general (eg. chemistry, psychology, sociology, etc.) and I didn't understand how a lot of the things were supposed to related to nutrition. I actually didn't like my major back then and wanted to switch out haha. But afterwards I started to really like the 3rd and 4th year courses b/c they were much more specific and interesting! If you're strong in sciences (which I'm not really), then nutrition is a good choice.
Most dietitians work in clinical (hospital), community, or food service positions. If you're really into cooking/food, you might like the food service component. I took this course last year that was super fun. The students and professor ran a restaurant on campus and we had to design menus, advertise our restaurant, cook the food, serve it, clean-up etc. The website for that restaurant is here if you're curious:
http://www.atriumrestaurant.uoguelph.ca
Let me know if you have any other questions! I'd say to major in something that you have interest in... not what you think will make the most money. But some ppl would say otherwise.
And thanks for the feedback. I'm glad to hear that you are enjoying some of my writings :)
I once got my body-fat percentage down to 3.4%. It sucked. I would be most interested in knowing what kind of diet/exercise scheme you should have to keep your energy levels as high as possible.
I have a healthy BMI but I still wonder whether I am really healthy, or fit. I do work out, well when I have the chance.
You are right! Just because you are skinny, does not mean you are healthy. People should start believing that.
What is inside will show up on the outside, sooner or later.
Not to sound morbid though.
I just found your blog today and I want to say you have already educated me more than womens health magazine, or any other website out there. I've been recovering from an injury for some time and so my workouts were minimized several months ago, and I had to start learning to watch what I ate. You have not only shown me some great fiteness and dietary alternatives, but I love your articles that talk about what "too skinny" is. You have helped me change my definition of healthy from skinny to fit.